Child 1: Riddles Wisely Expounded

The first ballad, which can be read here, is a story about a knight challenging a young girl to a game of riddles and offering to marry her if she can answer them right.  In most of the versions, such as the one sung here by the Askew Sisters, they get married at the end, though in others, such as this one sung by Jean Redpath, he turns out to be the devil and flies away “in a blazing flame.”

My first exposure to this ballad was the version recorded by Bok, Muir and Trickett under the name “Jennifer Gentle.”  Their version is very similar to version B in the book, which was taken from Gilbert’s Christmas Carols.  It is the sweetest and most innocent version collected by Child, and the only one where the youngest sister does not sleep with the knight before he asks her the questions.

In versions A, C and D, one of the questions is “what is worse than a woman was.”  I think there is something sad about the fact that this is being asked to a young woman by the man she wants to marry.  I do hate to see this kind of casual misogyny in the middle of a supposed love story.

Of course, in version C this question is used as a way to reveal that the knight is really the devil:

“The pies are greener nor the grass,

And Clootie’s waur nor a woman was.

“As sune as she the fiend did name,

He flew awa in a blazing flame.”

I prefer this ending.  I don’t like this guy and I think the girl can do better, devil or no devil.

So anyway, at the end the version A, which is one of the ones with a “happy” ending, we get this verse:

“So now, fair maidens all adieu,

This song I dedicate to you,

I wish that you may constant prove,

Unto the man that you do love.”

I just don’t know.  This is a song about a girl jumping through hoops to marry a guy in a riddle contest that bears more resemblance to a job interview than what we generally consider a “courtship,” the girl has to answer a question that starts with the assumption that women are evil, and all the narrator has to say in conclusion is “Hey women, be faithful!”  Lovely.

I know that there is some values dissonance going on here, but I reserve the right to judge these ballads from my own modern perspective.

I challenged myself to sing this song with a lot of the verses I don’t usually hear, resulting in a very long, repetitive recording.  You have been warned.

There was a lady of the North Country,

Lay the bent to the bonny broom

And she had lovely daughters three.

And you may beguile a fair maid soon.

There came a stranger to the gate,

And he three nights and days did wait.

He came unto the lady’s door,

And asked where her three daughters were.

“The eldest is to the washing gone,

The second is to the baking gone.

“The youngest is to a wedding gone,

And it will be night before they’re home.”

He sat him down upon a stone,

Till the three lasses came tripping home.

The oldest one’s to the bed making,

The second one’s to the sheet spreading.

But the youngest sister so bold and bright,

She lay abed with this uncouth knight.

And in the morning when it was grey,

These words to her did the stranger say.

Now answer me these questions three,

Or you shall surely go with me.

Now answer me these questions six,

Or you shall surely be old Nick’s.

What is sharper than the thorn?

What is louder than the horn?

What broader than the way?

What is colder than the clay?

What is greener than the grass?

And what is worse than a woman was?

Hunger is sharper then the thorn,

And thunder is louder than the horn.

Love is broader than the way,

And death is colder than the clay.

Envy’s greener than the grass,

And the Devil’s worse than a woman was.

As soon as she the fiend did name,

He flew away in a blazing flame.

This entry was posted in music, riddle song, traditional and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Child 1: Riddles Wisely Expounded

  1. Phil says:

    I’ve had this blog bookmarked for a while (since you linked back to mine) but I’ve only just started listening to your renditions of the songs, with this one. What a revelation! I’ve never heard R. W. E. before & wouldn’t have sought it out – endless renditions of Scarborough Fair have more or less killed the love+riddle genre for me. Or so I thought until I played the song.

    It’s a dreadful cliche, but hearing the song sung really does bring it to life. I’ll be learning this one now (after checking back with Child to see exactly which version(s) you used, of course).

    Keep up the good work, and I look forward to catching up!

    • djiril says:

      Thank you! It’s nice to know that someone appreciates what I’m doing here. I’ve been meaning to catch up on the recordings since I slacked off a bit after #4, but I do try to link to other people singing interesting versions of the songs.

  2. Fiona says:

    Wow. just wow. Your singing is truly lovely!

    And I like the version you sang. The answers to the questions are actually very interesting. “Hunger is sharper than the thorn” (And in the other version you quote “pies are greener nor the grass? Must be key lime pies lol ;-)…maybe it’s peas?)

    I believe “worse nor a woman was” is a reference to Eve in the Garden of Eden, and the correct answer is, of course, the Devil. Maybe this will make you feel better about that verse, one can see the answer as refuting the assumption, found in some medieval theology, that women are innately weak and prone to evil.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s